The magazines just continue coming, even though I've never signed up for them.
I keep them all, though. Craft supplies, I tell myself, as I jam issues of Travel + Leisure and Inc. and Vanity Fair into an already overfilled drawer. I haven't decoupaged or made a collage in years and my Girl Scout leadership days are on hiatus here in the desert, but I know all too well the feeling of needing something recently tossed out in the Monday recycling. So into the hutch drawer they go. I'll need to start in on another drawer soon.
I'm rifling through the mail on my way back from the box. Another magazine, but it's not one I recognize.
To be fair, I rarely recognize any of them over time. They're just bulky things that take up space in the box. And my hutch, as it would seem.
But this one is different.
Sin Eaters Digest.
I bring it in the house, to the kitchen island where I sort the two weeks' worth of mail that I left to fill our spot in the cluster box up the block. Credit card offers go in the recycle pile. Pay stubs from the side hustle that I can't seem to figure out how to make wholly paperless go into the keep pile. (Keep where? Another overstuffed drawer? Yes, the answer is always yes. Unopened, into a drawer. I already saw it online.) Mail to be opened and reviewed, those go into their own pile. Magazines off to the side.
Except this one.
I flip it over, then flip through it.
Sin Eaters Digest?
The headlining articles are:
"Fashion at the Feast."
"Current Standards for Compensation: We Ask 100 Sin Eaters What They Accept."
"Is Modern Therapy Co-Opting Sin Eating?"
I set the magazine down and pick up my phone - the Google Machine, as we're wont to call it in our house. I search the term and gain the context I'm so sorely missing.
I'm still on my phone, the magazine beside me on the couch, when my husband returns from work. By the time he heads out to the gym after dinner, I've read it from cover to cover. I've read a Wikipedia article about sin eating. I've read an AMA Reddit thread. I've read an article in Psychology Today about how social media content managers are developing PTSD and are being likened to modern-day sin eaters.
I've also learned that Psychology Today still has a print publication. Who knows how long it'll be before it shows up in my mailbox?
I go to bed that night still thinking about it.
It keeps me awake.
I'm a little angry about that. Perimenopause already steals enough sleep from me. I don't need one more thing.
I didn't subscribe to this.
But why does it resonate?
The issues keep coming. It seems like it's a weekly digest. Even if I don't physically go down to get the mail, I still have the USPS Informed Delivery app on my phone. I can see the headlining articles in the post office's scans of the covers.
"Today's Hottest New Sin Eating Musical Acts: We Build You a Brand New Playlist!"
"Embracing the Outcast Life."
"Vote for the Sexiest Sin Eater of 2026!"
"The Ethical Complications of Ambulance Chasing Sin Eaters."
"Crossing Party Lines - Would You Eat the Sins of Your Political Foes?"
"How to Brine Your Thanksgiving Turkey in the Sins of the Departed."
"Tips for Training Your Sin Eating Pooch."
"Mercury in Retrograde: The Best Time for Vicious Vittles?"
"Big Sin - Is a Brand Deal Right for You?"
"The Case for AI in Sin Eating."
Before I realize it, I've been getting copies of Sin Eaters Digest for six months. I've absolutely had to start a new drawer, but these ones get their own. It seems weird to stack them on top of Florence Pugh on the cover of Vanity Fair.
An issue arrives one day that misses the Informed Delivery scan. It happens. I was actually kind of surprised I was seeing them on the scans at all - usually magazines don't come through. I pull it out of the mailbox along with a Valpak and another pay stub that I can't seem to get to go paperless. On my way back to the house, I check out the headlining articles.
"Eldest Daughters: Natural Born Sin Eaters?"
I actually stop in my tracks, which sucks because I've stopped right by the house with the giant dog that hops on top of the brick wall and barks at me. He doesn't miss his cue. One day, he'll make it over the top. Today is not that day, but he perches there, barking in short spurts and then just staring at me. It breaks my sudden concentration.
"It's cool, homie," I tell him. "I'm leaving."
Back at the house, I sit down on the couch with the stack of mail and look at the headlining article again.
"Eldest Daughters: Natural Born Sin Eaters?"
This whole time that I've been transfixed by this magazine, I've only fleetingly wondered who it was for. Each time it arrives, there's no pre-printed address and bulk postage. Yet, it has to be the postal carrier depositing it into my box. The USPS scanning it at the distribution center. I know things can make it through if they're somehow coded properly. I always just assumed it was a renewal of a folded magazine that also was a renewal of a folded magazine. I'd briefly considered that it could have been for a previous tenant of our rental house. We still get their mail sometimes. There was that time I got the former occupant's butt-lifting leggings dropped off on my porch.
There's a reasonable explanation. There must be.
Right?
"Eldest Daughters: Natural Born Sin Eaters?"
Has the call been coming from inside the house the whole time?
The glaring metaphor is not lost on me now, though I clearly had to have it spoon-fed to me over the past few months. Maybe it's been years of the universe trying to scream a message at me that I should've been able to hear. It's my eyesight that's shitty, it's never been my ears. I can hear the bees in the tall grass of the backyard and I can hear the hum of electronics from the room over.
I'm the sin eater.
I've always been the sin eater.
When my younger sister was being my younger sister with all her transgressions and moral failings, I was expected to uphold my standing as the "good" one. The one no one worried about. The "easy" one that kept quiet and read books. Sit still, don't make a fuss.
When life threw me curveballs, asking for exactly the help I needed was seen as an offense. I should shoulder the weight quietly and never burden anyone else. I should eat the trauma and ingest it silently, without complaint. They weren't equipped to deal with me and I should accept that. With grace.
Be useful. Be helpful. Be kind, unfailingly so, even at your own soul's expense.
A quote from The Stand whizzes across my plane of consciousness: "It tastes terrible, so eat your pie. You can have seconds, even thirds. Eat your pie, Frannie, eat every bite."
Take your mother's generational trauma by the forkful. She doesn't mean it. It's her first time being human. She's doing her best. She'll never tell you her trauma and she'll never overtly lay it out on the table like dessert, like Frannie's pie, but it will be unprocessed and it will be passed along to you in oblique ways that sound like flat excuses when you speak them aloud.
The sin eater is the outcast, isolated. You'll spend your childhood both over- and under-mothered at the same time. Stay home, keep quiet, be good. It builds a weird wall between you and the rest of the world. You'll get called smart, but not street smart. Book smart, they mean, but unable to pick up on the complexities of humans.
Carry the labor alone. Know what they want before they ask for it. Behave like a well-adjusted grown-up even though you're still a child. Your behavior can't be tolerated because they have to tolerate everyone else's. There's no space for you unless you're making life easier.
Eat the pie.
Digest the sins.
Make it nice for the people.
I look down at the magazine again. I haven't even opened it this time.
I was the sin eater. I always have been.
This doesn't have to be mine.
This issue goes in the recycling. I empty the special drawer I freed up just for them.
Then they stop coming.
I don't miss them.
My chest feels lighter over time, as though I've released a breath I never knew I was holding.
The dog never makes it over the top of the wall and the other magazines keep coming. Country Living and Women's Health make their way into the mix. I refill the emptied drawer.
Maybe someday I'll decoupage again and I'll have a really great stash of magazines to rifle through, my good paper scissors in one hand and a bottle of Mod Podge in front of the other.
I didn't subscribe to these ones, either, but I don't mind the space they take up.